Pat Buchanan on Pope Benedict XVI
Catholic, GeneralBuchanan is blunt, controversial, and perceptive. These comments are no exception. Not only do I think he’s right on, but he’s incredibly funny. Contextually, he’s responding to the ravings of Andrew Sullivan. Here are the relevant parts from the April 19th episode of Scarborough Country:
SCARBOROUGH:
This is what [Andrew Sullivan] wrote recently in his blog: “Christians who are
saddened by the ascent of extremism and fundamentalism within their
faith communities have options other than passivity. They have the
blogosphere. Cardinal Ratzinger cannot silence us.”
Pat,
again, we have heard the charge, again and again, from moderates and
even from some conservatives, that he was the cardinal responsible for
silencing those that disagreed with Pope John Paul II.
BUCHANAN:
Look, Joe, when you say disagreed, Cardinal Ratzinger is responsible
for maintaining the truth of doctrine and dogma by which men reach
eternal life.
Andrew Sullivan is an open
homosexual. He has been living in that relationship, and he wonders
why the church doesn‘t change its doctrine and dogma to accommodate
him. It cannot. That is the truth Christ taught. Now, what Cardinal
Ratzinger is today is the vicar of Christ on earth. Now, Christ wasn‘t
terribly popular to the world he came into. He was crucified by that
world.
And today‘s world, especially this
hedonistic society we live in, materialistic, it wants the church to
accommodate to it. And the Holy Father‘s job is not to do that. It is
to speak truth to secular power. And that is what he is doing. That
is what he has done. There could not have been a better choice. Folks
who disagree with doctrine and dogma of the Roman Catholic Church,
there‘s lots of empty pews over in the Episcopal Church. They can head
over there.
(LAUGHTER)
BUCHANAN: But this man speaks the truth.
SCARBOROUGH: All right.
BUCHANAN: Now, listen, the flock has got a good German shepherd, Joe.
(LAUGHTER)